Monday, 24 September

Istanbul Armenians: The Diaspora’s “Outsiders”?



Arus Yumul, an Armenian sociologist who lectures at the Bilgi University in Istanbul, says that if the dominance of Muslims over non-Muslims during the Ottoman Empire was a hierarchical division, after the founding of the Republic in Turkey that difference theoretically disappeared, but that this phenomenon still exists today in Turkey but not in an overt way.

Yozge Genc, another expert with the Turkish Economic and Social Studies Foundation (TESEV), told me that the main problem of Armenians today in Turkey is that they are not regarded as full citizens of the Turkish state.

"Armenians are still identified by their religion and ethnic affiliation," says Genc, adding that the other minorities in Turkey have the same problem but that in the case of Armenians such a thing is expressed in a slightly different way.

 

Pakrat Estukyan, the Armenian edition editor at Agos weekly expressed the same thought, noting that at one time Armenians in Turkey constituted a nationality, a people, but that they had been reduced to a mere "community" today; and a religious one at that.

 

 For years the number of Armenians living in Turkey has hovered between 60,000 – 70,000 and that’s not counting the number of crypto-Armenians living in Anatolia and western Armenia. Experts say their number is quite large.

Estukyan said that even though only a citizen’s religion is noted in passports, government agencies have a good handle on nationality data as well.

As the largest non-Muslim minority in Turkey, Armenians are not represented in political or social sectors and do not hold state office. Yozge Genc said that the employment process for state office is quite complicated for Armenians, especially when national security issues come up.

Armenians serve on the Sisli Municipal Council, but it’s one district in Istanbul where most of the city’s non-Muslims reside.

 Ozge Genc says that an Armenian was recently assigned to the government’s Central Secretariat for EU Affairs, but this was a singular event. Mensur Akgun, Director of the Global Political Trends Center (GPOT) says that a lot has to do with personal and practical contacts and not just a person being Armenian.

Silvia Tiryaki, his deputy, says that the Turkish "deep-state" avoided assigning Armenians to top posts after the operations of ASALA in the 1970s and 1980s.

Pakrat Estukyan disagrees with this belief and stresses that the divide was created not because of ASALA but the 1915 Genocide; something the Turks don’t talk about.

Sociologist Yumul says that for the worldwide Armenian diaspora, the Istanbul-Armenian community is akin to a "lost lamb", an "outsider". She says that other Armenians have taken them to task for being non-active in Armenian affairs and for cow-towing to the government in Ankara. Yumul says she agrees with these assessments when it comes to the Ottoman period, but that after Turkish independence Armenians not only didn’t get involved in Armenian politics but also Turkish affairs. It was kind of a survival strategy she noted.

Yumul added that the community is slowly integrating into the larger Turkish society and that mixed marriages are paving the way.

"At one time Armenian parents resisted but this too has faded. The next generation will be more like a hybrid, free to chose whether they are Armenian, Turk..."

She was quick to add that this doesn’t mean that Armenians will disappear in Turkey.

However, the use of Armenian as a daily language of communication is also on the decline; the number of Armenians who can’t speak the mother tongue is growing. Parents send their kids to Armenian elementary schools but afterwards many go to private or foreign high schools so that they won’t have problems with the Turkish language in college.

The 1990s were a turning point for the community in many ways. Armenians, like the other minority communities, began to voice their concerns, speak about the discrimination they faced, and even raise the taboo subject of the 1915 Armenian Genocide

Twenty years ago, all this was unthinkable. What the next twenty will bring for the community remains a big question mark.

 


Home page


See also

more news



Related News

  • Armenians in Turkey
    I met Artur a little while ago. He was delivering an order from a shoe factory to my husband’s family. I noticed him, since in Istanbul you usually notice other Armenians. We saw on the doorstep and invited him inside.
  • Armenian Migrants in Turkey: An All Female Story
    Istanbul - the courtyard of the Armenian Church of Surp Hovhannes. Every evening, the coming and going of people intensifies with the setting of the sun.
  • They Moved to Turkey In Order to Buy a House In Armenia
    Artash says the police know everyone who is working illegally. It’s just a matter of not getting into trouble or making trouble. If you do, the authorities will let you go about your business.
  • A Stroll through Istanbul – Part 2
    Since she’s an old-timer, Ano watches out and cares for those who have recently migrated from Armenia. But she complains that the newcomers have cheated her in return.
  • Children of Armenia in Istanbul’s Labor Market
    Every day, 13 year-old Mamoukan must convince himself that he loves his boss more than his own father. Tough socio-economic conditions have even started to impact the emotions and views of adolescent citizens of Armenia.
... read more on "Turkey and Armenians"
Comments (4)
1. Vahe23:36 - 4 May, 2011
Wow, I really hope parents in Turkey make a conscientious effort to keep the language alive.
2. Dave00:06 - 6 May, 2011
Even if Armenians in Turkey were not afraid of getting murdered and were equal citizens, the fact remains that (1) Armenians in Turkey can easily be wiped out at any time and put into gas chambers en masse and no one except Armenians would lift a finger to help prevent it, and (2) there was a genocide which wiped out nearly every Armenian in Western Armenia. These problems can only be solved by the regaining of Western Armenia and its repopulation with Armenians. Even then, Turks are probably always going to try to annihilate Armenians. Turks are a permanent danger. I also want to mention that when Bolsetsi Armenians lobby against Armenian genocide recognition or other legislation by other countries, they make themselves look terribly stupid and unworthy of being listened to. For Bolsetsis to bow down to Turkey in that way just shows how beaten down they are.
3. chello08:12 - 6 May, 2011
Dave, You're a brave man talking from a cozy corner somewhere miles away from the reality confronting Armenians in Turkey. First you say that these Armenians could be easily wiped out and gassed at any moment and then take them to task for not rising up against their oppressors... Hmmm, 70,000 Istanbul-Armenians against a sea of 70,000,000 Turks, whom you call their mortal enemy. Will you go to Istanbuul and stand at the barricades with your brothers and sisters at the barricades when the Turkish hoards descend on them? I think not
4. shantagizoum07:28 - 10 May, 2011
IRABES CAVALI E HAY LINEL ISTANBULLA UM..BOLIS ASELOV HAYER PORCUM EN YEREVAGAYEL WOR DA DERYEVS CONSTANDNUBOLIS-N E....Yev iharge inchklan dzhvar gyank en varoum ayndex mert mnacortacn...cavok..cavok...ch´grcink-inchbes bidi user Antranik...¨GORCS GISDA MNAC¨ir verchin khoskern ein..ISK TE INCH EN KHORHOUM MER YERVANCI HAYER..netzav masamb-inchbes aysor didum ei 66rt HAXTANAGN EIN DONUM AYSBES ASAC H A R E N A G A N BADERAZMI---INCH HAYRENIK-I MEGN HARCENER ???? mer khayrenik vann i Ersroumi ...kars, surmalu ...PAREMIDNER...CHASELU HAMAR BARZAMIDNERE...YEV DER KHOSUM EN ARCANAGRUTYUNNERI(bROTOGOLnERI) HAMAR, fransahay mi gros grele mi girk(ink nakhabes Istanbull e bnagelis yexel yev Joxoberl) ESH NAHADAG HAY ZHOGHOVORUT...AGANJ KHOSI GAREGIN NJDEHI..YETE RSNER ISGAB ES MEZ SIRUM EIN YEV HARGUM GNAHADOUM MER NERDRMAN HAMAR 200/250,000 zoh DVAC HAYORTINER MINCHEV BERLIN...TO X ARNVAZN AYN 120 MILLION DOLAR I BARDK marac linein kani dari araj yev mer VETERANNERIN IPR HADUCUM -BAZHNEDER ANEIN YEV ZOHERI SHARAVIXNERIN...YEGAN GRAVECIN AYD GORCARANNER. ES EL MER KERI RUS@...HAYER KHELKI YEGEK...MEZ VOCH VOK CHI OKNI BACI INKNERES MEZI.YEGEK HINENK MER N E R D R M A N HIMNADRAM I GENEVE-MER 5/6 MAGNADNERI DRAMADNAYIN EXPERT NERI MIJOTSAVE YEV ABA MER ARCHI MIIONCHIKNER, MINCHEV HAZAARAGAN DOLAR NERDROGHNER YEV A 100 AGAN gnacek hashvek desek our g´hasniot mer FOND...ABA ARAJIN HERTIN ISGAGAN NERGAKHT YEV VOCH TE ¨¨Ä R I D U N¨¨¨kheghgadagutyun....amot!!!!!!!!!! HARCCREK INDZNIC TE INCHBES KICH HEDO DZE OUGARGEM BIDI ANGLIEREN IM DESUTYUN AYS ARTIV DENEM g´hradaragek?????? Hama haigagani SIRO.gaytzag palandjian
Leave a comment
Thank you for your comment. Your comment must be confirmed by the administration.

Archive